For all of the attention that Tanner Franklin and Liam Doyle get for the St. Louis Cardinals, and rightfully so, Brandon Clarke has the best stuff in the system. And that powerful fastball and nasty slider combination has earned him a comp to a potential Hall of Fame closer.
One reader asked Geoff Pontes, who covers the Cardinals system for Baseball America, where Pontes would rank on their updated list and if Clarke can stay on the mound enough to be a frontline starter, and Pontes provided an exciting comp from one talent evaluator.
"He'll be 14-16 area," Pontes wrote. "I got an Aroldis Chapman comp from one evaluator, and it's not crazy to think he has that upside as a closer. Not many lefties besides him and Aroldis popping 102-103 [mph]."
Chapman, like Clarke, had electric stuff on the mound and was brought up in the Cincinnati Reds system as a starter before settling in as a potential Hall of Fame closer. As much as I would love to see Clarke work out as a starter (and believe they should keep that option open as long as possible), you'd obviously love to see that kind of outcome for Clarke!
Brandon Clarke could be an elite closer for the Cardinals for a long time
Clarke's fastballs are special, but when you pair that with a plus-plus slider as well, that's an even better pitch; it's easy to see why Clarke could be a force on the mound whenever he is healthy.
"One of the most exciting, one of the most talented arms you’re going to find, probably in the entire game ... still a work in progress, but in terms of the arm talent, in terms of the upside, it’s as good as you’re going to find," Bloom said about Clarke back in July while joining "Sports on a Sunday Morning" on KMOX Sports with Tom Ackerman.
For Clarke, his main issue has been his health, as he's only thrown 38 innings and 29.2 innings during his first two seasons of professional baseball. He does have a walk issue as well, but since he strikes out 36.4% of the batters he faces and doesn't give up loud contact, it's not a huge issue if it doesn't dramatically improve.
Expecting the same level of career as Chapman is obviously not fair to Clarke. Chapman has turned his incredible stuff into 402 career saves in 873 innings of work over his 17-year career, owning a 2.48 ERA and 27.2 fWAR over that timeframe. With that being said, the comparison, talent-wise, is real.
Let's zoom out for a second. So you're telling me that a guy who, if he stays healthy, may have the best stuff of any starter in baseball, and if he moves to the bullpen, may be the next Chapman, is only going to rank in the 14-16 range on the Cardinals' prospects list? That's insane. It tells you what kind of system the Cardinals have right now, something Pontes himself has been raving about lately.
Pontes recently joined me for the Dealin' the Cards podcast and spoke at length about how the Cardinals' system is the best he's seen in baseball over the last five years. Yes, not just this year, but the best he's seen over the course of five seasons. If you want to get excited about the Cardinals farm system, I highly recommend listening to that episode.
Keep an eye on Clarke ahead of next season. If the Cardinals keep him in the rotation, we are likely a year or two away from seeing him, but if they transition him to the bullpen, we could see him lighting up the radar gun at Busch Stadium very soon.
