Skip to main content

Tanner Franklin has top prospect evaluator fired up about his future with the Cardinals

The Cardinals may finally have a true top-end starter on their hands.
ByJosh Jacobs
Springfield Cardinals v. Arkansas Travelers
Springfield Cardinals v. Arkansas Travelers | Braeden Botts/GettyImages

Tanner Franklin is coming, and if you don't know much about him yet, get ready, as he may be the best of the young St. Louis Cardinals pitching talent that will be breaking through in the coming years. Don't just take my word for it; listen to the praise Franklin got from Baseball America's Geoff Pontes.

Pontes, who covers the Cardinals farm system for Baseball America, joined the Dealin' the Cards podcast to break down this incredibly exciting group of prospects the Cardinals have right now, and couldn't stop raving about Tanner Franklin's upside.

"I'm as excited about Tanner Franklin as any pitching prospect in baseball," Pontes said as he lit up about Franklin's profile. "I think you saw that progression. You see the physicality and the type of stuff. It looks like Gerrit Cole. He's not going to be Gerrit Cole, but it's like a big right-hander that has weird angles and a ton of power and spin capacity. There's just not a lot of guys that fit into that bucket. I've heard other people compare him to Zach Wheeler, some of his arsenal is similar to Wheeler. But you're talking about frontline right-handers here, right? Those are the kind of guys he's comparing to...In my personal list, he'll probably be like top 30, 35, maybe top 25 [on his personal top 100 prospects list]."

Franklin, who was drafted by the Cardinals with the 72nd pick in the 2025 MLB Draft, was primarily a reliever in college but was dynamic as a starter in his first full professional season, striking out 29.8% of the batters he faced while covering 105 innings on the mound. Franklin got more and more comfortable as the season went along, and by his final four starts, he was consistently pitching into or finishing the sixth inning.

Franklin's four-seam fastball and cutter grade out extremely well by Stuff+ metrics, and he pairs that plus-plus fastball and plus cutter with above-average breaking balls and a recently developed two-seam fastball that could be an average offering. He's got the stuff to be a problem on the mound, the physicality to hold up over the course of a season, and so far, the results that point to a ton of success coming his way.

Tanner Franklin could join the Cardinals rotation as soon as 2027

This isn't the first time Franklin has received such high praise from third-party outlets. Keith Law had him as a top-50 prospect in baseball this past season, and Baseball America had Franklin in the Cardinals' top five prospects before most others did. And any time you talk to someone with the Cardinals, you'll hear similar praise for what he can offer on the mound.

Pontes agreed that Franklin, if he continues his trajectory, could join the Cardinals rotation even by midseason in 2027. Franklin, alongside Liam Doyle, Tekoah Roby, Jurrangelo Cijntje, and Mason Molina, plus the recently debuted Quinn Mathews and Cooper Hjerpe, could all help transform the Cardinals' pitching staff next season into a really scary group.

Throughout the podcast, Pontes dove in depth into why the Cardinals farm system is the best he's seen over the last five years, with talent up and down in levels, both on the mound and in the field. The Cardinals haven't had this much talent in the system at least since the early 2010s, when the rest of baseball was raving about how they develop talent.

Franklin is also my personal favorite of the bunch, but, like you'll hear in the podcast, Doyle, Cijntje, Roby, Mathews, Brandon Clarke, Tegan Kuhns, and others all have front-line or strong middle-of-the-rotation-type potential, something the Cardinals haven't had in quite some time. Once they start filling up the rotation, this team is going to be ready to make some noise.

So while the Cardinals may not make a bunch of moves this offseason to improve the Major League roster, I strongly disagree with the premise that they don't think they can compete next season. As these young arms and position players continue to break through in 2027, the team could be positioned to surprise a ton of people before heading into their true contention window in 2028 and beyond.

Add us as a preferred source on Google