Skip to main content

3 Cardinals rookies among top 10 in 2027 projections

Hard to argue against these expectations.
ByScott Plaza
MLB: SEP 26 Cardinals at Brewers
MLB: SEP 26 Cardinals at Brewers | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

The St. Louis Cardinals have fully committed to their rebuild and hope 2027 will be another step in the right direction. After unloading veterans and expiring contracts, Chaim Bloom looks ready to begin next season with a similar roster that ended the 2026 campaign.

That major league squad consisted of Silver Slugger finalists and a Rookie of the Year finalist on the offensive side and a staff full of mid-rotation talent on the mound. Supplementing those players next year are a trio of prospects who are locked into a spot on the 2027 roster after solid major league debuts of their own. Quinn Mathews, Joshua Baez, and Leo Bernal all flashed in small sample sizes this year and are projected to build off those performances.

3 debuted Cardinals prospects could make a run for 2027 Rookie of the Year

For good reason, much of the prospect hype surrounding the St. Louis Cardinals has been built around teenage catching wunderkind Rainiel Rodriguez. Even after getting named the organization's minor league player of the year, Rodriguez will still need to make a stop in Memphis before gracing the St. Louis faithful with his star-studded potential at Busch. While we sit and wait for Hulk to make his debut, we will have plenty to still be excited about as all of Mathews, Bernal, and Baez are expected to have major roles in 2027 and beyond.

The Steamer projections for a full 2027 just released and while the whole of the expected Cardinals roster does not do much to inspire confidence for wins, it is these rookies who really stood out in the group. The projections unsurprisingly have JJ Wetherholt, Masyn Winn, Ivan Herrera, and Alec Burleson as the team leaders in fWAR on the position player side with Kyle Leahy, Andre Pallante, Michael McGreevy, and Matthew Liberatore leading the pitchers. Unfortunately, only Wetherholt's projection puts him among the top NL players as the rest of the group will be found much lower in the rankings. When that list is filtered from all player to rookies, however, the Cardinals have to love where they stand.

Among rookies in both leagues, Bernal is the highest-ranked NL position player while both Baez and Mathews round out the top 10 on the list. Bernal's stellar start to his big-league career and his ability to handle a demanding position at catcher could make him an early frontrunner for the 2027 Rookie of the Year award. Baez made history with his incredible three-homer debut, but we also got a glimpse of his shortcomings that make me wary about his overall long-term career trajectory. For Mathews, he finally got his extended shot in the majors and made enough solid starts to be penciled into next year's rotation.

An fWAR around 2.0 means those players are expected to be right around league average and they rank around 125th in baseball. Position players and pitchers accrue WAR in different ways and positions, defense, and playing time all factor into that final number. It is admittedly a stat that has some flaws, but the ability to find one number that summarizes an entire season is a helpful measure of value. Based on the numbers, FanGraphs is predicting the Cardinals to finish slightly better than last year and currently have a 79-win total expectation.

Add us as a preferred source on Google