The non-tender deadline always brings change. It changed the Cardinals, who said goodbye to a former top prospect, Nolan Gorman. Hopefully, it will also give St. Louis new options in the free agent pool.
One of the league’s newest free agents is right-handed reliever Fernando Cruz. The former Yankee should be a premier target for the Cardinals.
Former Yankee Fernando Cruz would make a perfect Cardinal
What was the biggest ailment of the 2026 Cardinals season? The bullpen. Far and away, the bullpen.
At times, saves were hard to come by. Additionally, holds were a mystery. Cardinal closer Riley O’Brien had spells of dominance, but the bridge to the backend was always flimsy.
Cruz, 36, was a late-bloomer in the Bronx.
If the name sounds familiar, it’s because he was a Cincinnati Red from 2022 to 2024. After seeing his toolkit from afar, the Yankees pried him away, and he’s served them well the past two seasons.
This past year was particularly effective, which is why the non-tender decision comes as such a surprise.
In 54.2 innings, Cruz held a 3.13 ERA, 1.2 bWAR, two saves, and K’d 67. Walks were an off-and-on issue (5.3 per nine, 1.34 WHIP), but his 11 Ks per nine kept him afloat.
What have the Cardinals been trying to add? Strikeouts and upside. Few players offer that combination and will come for cheap.
Cruz’s go-to pitch is a fantastic splitter that generated whiffs 52% of the time and held opponents to an xBA of .161. He backs it up with a good sweeper and a for-show heater.
If the Cardinals want to start and play baseball like POBO Chaim Bloom’s former franchise, the Rays, they’ll need wrinkles. They’ll need individuals who do specific things better than anyone else. Cruz may very well have baseball’s best splitter.
Furthermore, if the Cardinals miss a reunion with setup specialist JoJo Romero, they’ll need someone to man the eighth.
Cruz brings New York-sized experience, a bumblebee splitter, and projectability based on big-league performance. That is exactly what St. Louis needs. This is a no-brainer.
