Skip to main content

Orioles superstar Gunnar Henderson is an interesting Cardinals trade target

I had a friend named Gunnar.
ByAJ Stone
Toronto Blue Jays v Baltimore Orioles - Game One
Toronto Blue Jays v Baltimore Orioles - Game One | Mitchell Layton/GettyImages

Multiple sources in Cardinals media anticipate St. Louis will be much more active in trade talks than in the free agent market. Could one of those trade fits be Orioles’ superstar Gunnar Henderson? 

The Cardinals have a few clear needs this offseason. First and foremost: the bullpen. After that, though, it gets much less clear. 

Nathan Church remains a question mark in center field, Masyn Winn’s offensive profile has come into question, and third base has been a black hole since Nolan Arenado started to decline in 2024. 

In light of recent events, the latter issue is particularly interesting. 

According to Will Sammon of The Athletic, the Orioles have decided not to pursue a contract extension with Henderson, and he is a trade candidate. 

Henderson, 25, is coming off a career-worst season in which he produced 3.2 bWAR, smashed 24 home runs, and played 158 games. 

The former 2023 AL Rookie of the Year has seen a downturn, but remains productive with elite fielding metrics and power. 

As a big leaguer, Henderson has spent most of his time at shortstop. Still, given his Six-foot-three, 230lb frame and cannon arm, his transition to third base projects as fairly effortless. 

If the Cardinals traded for Henderson, they’d add an impact position player through the 2028 season. The likelihood of extending him is small. His agent is Scott Boras; he plays a premier position, and he hits the open market before turning 30. 

That leads us to two questions: Is it worth it? And what would it take? 

Overall, committing to a player like Henderson feels shortsighted when there’s legitimate talent waiting in the Cardinals' prospect ether. 

Jesus Baez, who smashed over 40 homers last season and was just added to the Cardinals' 40-man roster, should get ample MLB opportunities by 2028. If that were the case, and the Cards plugged holes with projects, they’d be face-palming by the time all the young talent was ready to fire. 

Furthermore, with other contenders like the Braves rumored to be heavily surveilling the shortstop market, Henderson’s price will be through the roof. 

Here’s what a realistic package might look like for the All-Star shortstop: 

Cardinals receive: Gunnar Henderson (SS)

Orioles receive: Liam Doyle (STL #2, LHP), Trevor Condon (STL #7, OF), Thomas Saggese (UTL)

Yes, that’s a lot. Yes, that’s probably close to what it’d take. 

If the Braves offer up left-handed flamethrower Cam Caminiti in a prospect package, St. Louis can top it–but it’d take your top-end guys. And the Braves would be wise to utilize top prospects in trades, as they’re close to competing for a ring. 

This is another “trade fit” that looks a lot better than it really is. The Cardinals spent years trying to offload another struggling third baseman. Henderson is younger, cheaper, and projects to improve, but that doesn’t mean that now is the right time for St. Louis to make this kind of move. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google