Five trade deadline candidates that can give the St Louis Cardinals their ace in the hole

St. Louis Cardinals Archive
St. Louis Cardinals Archive / St. Louis Cardinals, LLC/GettyImages
2 of 5
Next

The St. Louis Cardinals are in prime position to trade for an ace at the deadline, which ones could they target?

It might be March, but the need for a true number-one pitcher has been glaring for years for the St. Louis Cardinals. Many pitchers will be free agents after this season with much uncertainty moving forward for the pitching staff.

John Mozaliak has made it clear that the team will wait to pursue other available options throughout the season versus spending to spend during the 2022-2023 offseason. So what candidates could he be looking at? Here are five options that will give the Cardinals the next step toward winning a World Series in 2023.

Chris Sale

Chris Sale has been a major liability post the 2018 World Series for the Boston Red Sox. He signed a 5 year, $145 million (fully guaranteed) extension as his reward for being the main horse for Boston. This move has aged equal to the Stephen Strasburg extension. Sale has pitched 194.50 innings since the extension started in 2019.

He has not pitched badly, the problem is getting on a field to pitch. Sale has missed so much time, injuries including rib fractures, broken wrists, and Tommy John surgery. The Red Sox would love to shed this contract, and Sale would love to show the league that he still has value to the team. With 55 million still owed over the next two seasons, maybe the Cardinals can pick up part of the tab?

Trade proposal: Alec Burleson, Paul DeJong, Jonathan Mejia, and Connor Thomas for Chris Sale and 20 million (AAV of 17.5 million for 2 seasons of control)

Zac Gallen

Hello old friend!

Remember the worst trade in recent Cardinals history? What if we can salvage part of it? Sandy Alcantara is untouchable now after winning the 2022 NL Cy Young award. But Zac Gallen was also really good in 2022. His slash line was 12-4, 2.54 ERA (158 ERA+), 192 SO, and .913 WHIP in 184 IP. That incredible season for a very disappointing Diamondbacks team led to a 5th place finish in Cy Young voting.

The D-Backs look good on paper for 2023, but this team is not going to make the playoffs. With three more years of control, will the Dbacks consider trading Gallen to a desperate team and get a solid haul in return to further complete the post-Paul Goldschmidt rebuild? The Cardinals would like to rewrite history.

Trade Proposal: Gordon Graceffo, Michael McGreevy, and Moises Gomez for Zac Gallen

Shane Bieber

This is the move most of the fanbase wants. And it is for good reason. Shane Bieber made a loud entrance into the league in 2019 and has continued his dominance. His 2022 slashline was 13-8, 2.88 ERA (132 ERA+) 198 SO, 1.040 WHIP in 200 IP. This performance landed him a seventh place finish in the AL Cy Young voting.

But this is just a machine pumping out the same results every year. He finished 4th in Cy Young in 2019 and won the Cy Young in 2020. He was an All-Star in 2021 but did not place in any awards due to injuries. But since his arrival, it has been all high innings pitched, low ERAs, and high strikeout rates using great control of the zone.

With Cleveland in a very weak division, they are the heavy favorites to win the AL Central. But…..what if the Twins and White Sox ruin their fun? Then you could see the Guardians trading their stars like the track record shows.

Trade proposal: Nolan Gorman, Tyler O'Neill,  Dakota Hudson, and Gordan Graceffo for Shane Bieber. 

Dylan Cease

Dylan Cease had a breakout during the 2022 season. He produced a 14-8, 2.20 ERA (180 ERA+, 227 SO, 1.109 WHIP in 184 IP. That level of dominance placed him in second for the AL Cy Young award behind the timeless Justin Verlander. Cease had a good 2021 but nothing that displayed ace-level production. 2022 was a wake-up call to the league, and his presence was definitely announced.

He is a favorite for the 2023 betting odds on winning the 2023 Cy YoungThe most recent spring training outing was the far opposite of what Dylan Cease can do, but could it be a sign of something else? But after the abysmal season the White Sox had under Tony La Russa, can the team turn the tide moving forward? Or is it time to reconsider this 40-man roster and try again? Maybe the Cardinals' depth can help.

Trade Proposal: Lars Nootbaar, Matthew Liberatore, Ivan Herrea, and Luken Baker for Dylan Cease

Aaron Nola

The Phillies just won the NL Pennant….why would they trade Aaron Nola? Let's talk about it.

The NL East is the toughest division in baseball by far. The Mets have retooled, the Braves are maturing and are getting more dangerous, and the two Wild Card spots can go to anyone which makes it harder for Philly to squeeze their way in again. Bryce Harper is out possibly until the All-Star break, Trea Turner is going to be adjusting to a new team, and Nicholas Casteanllos has much to prove to provide depth to the lineup.

The Phillies are expected to be a powerhouse in 2023, but the worst-case scenario is: what happens if they fall apart? Are they willing to sign Aaron Nola to an extension? Or will they trade him at the deadline in hopes to sign him back in the offseason? The Cardinals can offer a nice package to entice the Phillies and give the Cardinals the ace they have been looking for going into October.

Trade Proposal: Dylan Carlson, Joshua Baez, and Luken Baker for Aaron Nola

Next. Cardinals with most to prove at the WBC. dark

Next