Roughly 15 months ago, a hotshot young pitcher came into St. Louis and shut down the Cardinals over 5⅓ innings, allowing just one run en route to a Yankees win. Today, he's a free agent, having been non-tendered in a shocking decision by the New York front office.
Luis Gil won the AL Rookie of the Year award just two years ago, but back and elbow injuries have limited him to 84⅓ innings ever since. His surface results in that time, including a 3.74 ERA, don't look too bad, but a 5.44 FIP and 1.41 WHIP is more telling. He simply didn't click with the development program the Yankees had planned out for him.
Now available to every team, the Cardinals should take a long, hard look at Gil in free agency. He's lost some of his shine recently, but there's frontline starter potential to uncover as well.
Cardinals can succeed where Yankees failed with Luis Gil's development
When Gil was at his best in 2024, everything played off his fastball. He used the pitch roughly half of the time, feasting in the upper-third of the zone. That allowed his slider (to righties) and changeup (to lefties) to dominate on the out-and-away edge of the plate.
Injuries have clearly played their role in his decline, as his fastball has lost more than a full tick on the radar gin in the past two years. He's only 28 years old, so there's plenty of time for him to get his premium velocity back, but his next team will need to be confident that they can help him restore it.
The Cardinals, who just had a lot of success helping rebuild another fastball-heavy pitcher (Dustin May) in 2026, could thus be the perfect landing spot. The coaching staff really leaned into May's three-fastball mix when he was on the team, which could directly translate to more sinker usage (Gil's seldom-used fourth pitch) for the current free agent.
If nothing else, more heaters should help mitigate some of Gil's control problems, which have haunted him dating back even to his best days; during that ROY campaign, he led all of baseball in walks issued (77). That is another area the Redbirds have some expertise in, since their 2026 rotation ranked 11th in walk rate (7.8%).
Whether it's with the intention of signing and flipping him (à la May) or trying to reestablish him as a mid-rotation piece, it would behoove the Cardinals to give Luis Gil a chance. They could certainly use his upside on the pitching staff if everything starts clicking again.
