I'm fully convinced the St. Louis Cardinals are going to be a better team in 2027, one that will make a strong push for the playoffs if things continue to progress with their young talent.
But if you look at social media or even others who cover the team, there seems to be a sentiment that since the Cardinals don't plan to be "aggressive" this offseason, 2027 is actually just a repeat of 2026. I couldn't disagree more.
We saw throughout the 2026 season that as the Cardinals' young talent started to break through and perform, the team improved. In 2027, they'll get continued progression from some, full seasons for the first time from others, and even more exciting talent joining the ranks. Sure, a free agent or two or trading for someone can help, but I think many have severely underrated how much the Cardinals can improve from within in 2027.
Here are five reasons why I believe the Cardinals are going to be better than most people expect in 2027.
1. JJ Wetherholt is set for a sophomore jump at the plate
All JJ Wetherholt has done is hit since bursting onto the national scene at the University of West Virginia, and prior to his wrist injury, he was doing the same in his rookie campaign.
Wetherholt's .242/.339/.365 slash line and 101 wRC+ as a rookie was a really solid start to his big-league career, but Wetherholt managed to post a 114 wRC+ and .755 OPS during the first half before falling off a cliff as he tried to battle through wrist pain.
I recently had Paul Hembekides from ESPN on the Dealin' the Cards podcast, and as a Philly native, he likened Wetherholt's ceiling to that of future Hall of Famer Chase Utley, and kept reiterating that he believed Wetherholt is a better hitter than what we saw in 2026.
The Cardinals' lead-off hitter was 1% above league average at the plate in 2026. If he takes a big step forward and is more like 15%-20% above average at the plate in 2027, that will go a long way toward helping the Cardinals' lineup produce more runs. And truthfully, I think he can be even better than that.
2. Eleteric pitching started to debut in 2026 and will flood the Cardinals staff in 2027
The Cardinals saw a step forward from their rotation in 2026, getting near top-10 production from that group while mostly relying on young arms in the process. Their bullpen, on the other hand, really let them down, especially in the second half.
Good thing a whole lot of reinforcements are on their way.
While talking with Geoff Pontes from Baseball America on Dealin' the Cards, he agreed that the Cardinals are on the rise and could be a real problem soon, and one of the main reasons for that optimism is just how much pitching is on its way to St. Louis. And it's the kind of pitching the Cardinals have lacked for a long time.
We got glimpses of that upside in the form of Quinn Mathews and Cooper Hjerpe in their debuts. Mathews showed that he can be a highly effective starter already, and Hjerpe's swing-and-miss is legit. Both can now contribute to the Cardinals' pitching staff for a full season.
Now imagine adding Tekoah Roby (whose stuff looked incredible in the Arizona Fall League), Jurrangelo Cijntje (whose right-arm was masterful once he gave up switch-pitching), Tanner Franklin and Liam Doyle (two top 50 prospects in the sport), and other arms like Mason Molina, Sandro Santana, Jacob Odle, Richard Fitts, Daniel Eagen, Brian Curely, and more.
There's a good chance multiple of those arms join Mathews and Hjerpe on the Opening Day roster; others will make their appearances soon after, and by August, their pitching staff may look completely different and ready to take things to the next level.
3. Full seasons of Leo Bernal and Joshua Baez
Believe it or not, Leo Bernal (125 wRC+) and Joshua Baez (113 wRC+) ranked second and fourth, respectively, in wRC+ among all Cardinals with at least 100 plate appearances in 2026. Now imagine getting their bats in the lineup for a full season.
Bernal finished sixth on the team in fWAR despite only playing in 24 games. He's a plus-to-plus-plus defender behind the plate who already has the trust of the Cardinals' pitching and coaching staffs, and pairs that with legit offensive production.
I don't necessarily expect Bernal to be 25% above league average again in 2027, but it's hard to overstate how much better the Cardinals lineup looks at full strength now that he's in it.
Same with Baez, whose power was on full display since literally the first pitch he saw of his big-league career, and now he will have the ability to mash in left field on a daily basis to take the Cardinals' lineup to the next level. Left field and catcher were two of the Cardinals' weakest spots offensively in 2026, so it's hard to overstate how much of an upgrade they would be over what they had.
4. The arrival of Rainiel Rodriguez and Jesus Baez (and maybe even Tai Peete)
Speaking of arrivals, Rainiel Rodriguez is the best Cardinals hitting prospect since Oscar Taveras, and Jesus Baez is coming off a 40+ home run campaign this past season. Adding those two bats to the lineup can take things to a whole other level.
Any time a prospect makes their debut, it's not fair to expect them to be impact players immediately, and either or both could struggle early on. But in the case of Rodriguez, if he's shown us anything as a prospect thus far, it's that he's a truly special hitter, one that will mash in St. Louis rather quickly. And adding that kind of bat over what will likely be a more mediocre bat in the lineup is a major facelift.
Same with Baez, who could factor in at third base or even spend some time at shortstop for St. Louis.
Assuming one or both of those guys can fill the gap at third base, center field would become the main weakness in the lineup, and Tai Peete could bring upside and flair to the position before the season's end.
2027 is the year of the pitcher for St. Louis when it comes to debuts, but the fewer position players who could join them each have the chance to be special contributors, especially Rodriguez.
5. Ivan Herrera returns to producing like a top-end bat
There's a world where Ivan Herrera is no longer on this team come Opening Day, the trade deadline, or next offseason, but if he is wearing a Cardinals uniform, he's going to provide far more production at the plate than he did last season.
From 2023 to 2025, Herrera's 133 wRC+ ranked 22nd in all of baseball among the 310 hitters with at least 750 plate appearances over that stretch. In 2026, that production fell all the way down to just a 109 wRC+. I don't think it is going out on a limb to say that Herrera is much closer to the guy he was from 2023-2025 than the guy he was in 2026.
2025 was a career year for Herrera, slugging 19 home runs and driving in 66 runs in just 107 games, and his 137 wRC+ was a truly elite mark. But after playing a career-high 161 games and catching on a more regular basis, he couldn't keep the production up at the plate. He honestly looked tired and possibly even hurt as the season went on, with Herrera's fast swing% falling quite a bit along the way.
Think about a lineup where you have Jordan Walker and Alec Burleson, who both drove in over 100 runs in 2026, flanked by an improved Wetherholt, a rebound from Herrera, full seasons from Bernal and Baez, and the debuts of Rodriguez, Baez, and Peete...oh, and with power pitching all over their rotation and bullpen.
Yeah, I think the Cardinals are going to be a pretty darn good team in 2027.
