Skip to main content

The Cardinals should inquire on a deal for flawed but promising Casey Schmitt

A one-for-one trade could work wonders for the Cardinals and Giants.
ByJ.T. Buchheit
Los Angeles Angels v San Francisco Giants
Los Angeles Angels v San Francisco Giants | San Francisco Giants/GettyImages

Major League Baseball appears headed for a long work stoppage, but that's not cooling down the hot stove in the offseason, and one recently announced trade candidate could fit the St. Louis Cardinals' biggest position of need — assuming the Cardinals trust their new development staff to mitigate a massive bugaboo in his game.

The San Francisco Giants have reportedly announced that they are willing to listen on offers regarding 27-year-old utility player Casey Schmitt. Schmitt broke out in 2026, hitting .271 with a .784 OPS while adding 21 home runs. He also played five different positions, seeing time in left field and at first base, second base, shortstop and — most importantly for the Cardinals — third base.

Of all the positions, he was most defensively proficient at third, at five outs above average, but Matt Chapman is entrenched at the position for the Giants. The Giants also have most of Schmitt's other positions spoken for, with Willy Adames, Bryce Eldridge, Rafael Devers and Marcelo Mayer expected to get the first cracks at shortstop, first base, designated hitter and second base, respectively. Left field is more open, but Schmitt did not grade well defensively there in 2026.

There's plenty of red on Schmitt's Baseball Savant page, but he has a gaping deficit in his plate discipline. Although he was having a strong season in the batter's box before tearing his meniscus in July, Schmitt had the lowest walk rate in the major leagues among hitters with at least 400 plate appearences, at just 2.7%.

That number may appear to portend doom for Schmitt in 2027 if pitchers wise up to his game, but with the Cardinals' now-vaunted coaching staff, it's not out of the question to think that Schmitt could rebound to somewhere around his more acceptable 7.8% walk rate that he put up in 2025. The Giants as a whole had the worst walk rate in the major leagues last season, so it may have been a teamwide approach for San Francisco rather than a terminal flaw in Schmitt's game.

The Cardinals are reportedly interested in a stopgap solution at the hot corner, but Schmitt would likely be a more long-term answer. If the Cardinals choose to take that route, they could look to move Jesús Báez to shortstop when he reaches the major leagues and dangle the slick-fielding Masyn Winn in trade talks. With President of Baseball Operations Chaim Bloom seeming less defensively inclined than manager Oli Marmol, it's not out of the question for St. Louis to sacrifice some middle infield acumen for more thump at the plate.

But because the Giants already have shortstop accounted for, Winn doesn't appear to fit their plans. Instead, San Francisco is looking for rotation help, and the Cardinals have a player whom they could realistically swap with the Giants in a one-for-one deal.

Michael McGreevy for Casey Schmitt could satisfy both the Cardinals and the Giants

Logan Webb and Landon Roupp are projected to head the Giants rotation, but it's a black hole beyond that. Michael McGreevy helped the Cardinals keep their heads above water for much of 2026, holding a 3.95 ERA, and his 1.9 fWAR is identical to that of Schmitt. After the hurler's solid year, the "Dealin' the Cards" podcast made a case for trading McGreevy given St. Louis' boatload of pitching depth.

Although McGreevy's pitch-to-contact approach could make some teams leery, much like Busch Stadium, San Francisco's Oracle Park is also notoriously pitcher-friendly. It's worth noting, though, that the Cardinals were far superior to the Giants in the field in 2026, and a strong defense may be important to McGreevy's success.

If the Cardinals were to deal McGreevy, their rotation at the beginning of the season would likely comprise Kyle Leahy, Andre Pallante, Quinn Mathews and Matthew Liberatore, with a potential cheap free agent like former Cardinals prospect Zac Gallen serving as a temporary piece in the first half a la Dustin May until Tekoah Roby, Richard Fitts or someone else is ready to run with the role.

Schmitt is entering his first year of arbitration eligibility and is projected to receive a salary of around $2.5 million, an easily affordable price for the Cardinals, even with several players facing raises in arbitration.

The lone player-for-player swap isn't a common one in baseball, but the Cardinals and Giants each hold fairly young, cost-controlled talent who could provide some value to the other club. If the Cardinals are confident in their philosophy under new hitting coach Joel McKeithan and can get Schmitt's plate discipline on track, he could benefit St. Louis in 2027 and further down the road.

Add us as a preferred source on Google