Skip to main content

Predicting who the Cardinals will protect from the Rule 5 draft ahead of Tuesday's deadline

There are many players with intriguing cases, but who will the Cardinals actually protect?
ByJosh Jacobs
Springfield Cardinals v. Arkansas Travelers
Springfield Cardinals v. Arkansas Travelers | Caton Marsh/GettyImages

Tuesday is Major League Baseball's deadline for teams to protect elgible prospects from the Rule 5 draft, and while there's a good chance the event ends up being cancelled due to the impending lockout, the St. Louis Cardinals won't be taking any chances when it comes to some of their prospects.

The Rule 5 draft is a mechanism in place that helps teams add young talent to their Major League roster and fight against other organizations hoarding young talent for too long. If a player is selected, they must be added to that club's 40-man roster and remain on that team's MLB roster for the entire following season, or be offered back to their parent club.

Teams have until 5 p.m. Central Time on Tuesday to select which players they want to add to their 40-man roster to protect from the draft. Who will the Cardinals choose? Here are my predictions ahead of the deadline.

INF Jesus Baez

Jesus Baez is about as slam-dunk of a choice to add to the 40-man roster as any prospect elgible this year.

Acquired in the Ryan Helsley trade at the 2025 trade deadline, Baez had an excellent season with the Cardinals this year, slashing .283/.328/.587 with 39 home runs and 109 RBI between High-A and Double-A, and slugging a few more home runs in the Double-A playoffs to add to those eye-popping numbers. Baez is a shortstop prospect and could push Masyn Winn for his job very soon, but also has the option to slide to third base or second base long-term as well.

Baez earned himself quite the jump in the Cardinals' prospect rankings during Baseball America's reveal of their top 10 Cardinals prospects ahead of 2027, and given how close he is to a Major League debut, the Cardinals should be taking zero chances when it comes to protecting Baez.

RHP Jacob Odle

Drafted in the 14th round of the 2023 MLB Draft, Odle burst onto the prospect scene this year, pairing his electric stuff with dominant performances that make him a very interesting candidate to be selected in the Rule 5 draft.

While Odle is likely a few years away from being a true Major League-caliber starting pitcher, his stuff has a really good chance of playing in a bullpen today, and opposing teams could try to stash him as a reliever in 2027 and then figure out his future as a starter following that.

Even with how deep the Cardinals' pitching is right now down on the farm, it makes too much sense not to protect Odle as things currently stand. There is so much potential in his arm, and considering the Cardinals found a way to carry multiple injured MiLB arms on their 40-man roster last season in Cooper Hjerpe, Tekoah Roby, Richard Fitts, and Tink Hence, the Cardinals can surely do the same with a healthy Odle.

I would expect Odle to begin the 2027 season in the Springfield Cardinals rotation, and if all goes well, he may be an option to debut in 2028. If starting games becomes an issue for him, or he can't leapfrog the Cardinals' other dynamic starting pitching prospects, they can easily move him into a bullpen role and see how the stuff plays.

Add us as a preferred source on Google