This is how the St. Louis Cardinals can find playing time for all of their young bats
With so many players needing every day at-bats, the Cardinals can get creative to find them all playing time
The St. Louis Cardinals have a variety of questions they need to answer as they head into the 2023 season. How will their rotation hold up and when will they add arms to it? How good is their bullpen? Which relievers deserve to make the Opening Day roster?
But the question that may be the hottest among the fan base right now actually has to do with a really, really good problem to have. With so many position players worth of playing time to start the year, how will the Cardinals find consistent at-bats for all of them?
This is a very real, and very important question that the Cardinals' front office and coaching staff will have to answer as they approach Opening Day and the early parts of the season. But let's be clear, this is a very good spot to be in. Some fans have taken this "uncertainty" as a sign that the Cardinals just don't have "clear options" for their starting lineup. It's quite the opposite. St. Louis has so many good options that it's hard to know who will actually be able to play for them.
While the tendency when looking at potential lineups is to think of the team's best nine players and leave little room for anyone else, that's just not how teams view roster construction these days. Oli Marmol showed last year that he wants to be creative with how lineups are constructed depending on matchups, hot hands, and proper rest for players. This creates a lot of extra opportunities for players to find at-bats and will be the key to the Cardinals getting all of their players enough playing time.
Brandon Kiley of 101 ESPN captured this really well last week, and I think it's worth looking at his chart for an idea of how the Cardinals playing time could be broken down early in the season.
The Cardinals' important bats get plenty of opportunities each week
Below is the chart that Kiley posted last week, which gives a really good picture of what playing time disbursement could look like.
Here are the start breakdowns by player based off Kiley's mock week outlook.
6 starts - Nolan Arenado
5 starts - Paul Goldschmidt, Willson Contreras, Jordan Walker, Tyler O'Neill, Nolan Gorman and Tommy Edman
4 starts - Brendan Donovan, Lars Nootbaar, and Dylan Carlson
3 starts - Juan Yepez
1 start - Backup catcher and Paul DeJong
Starts to make a lot of sense right? Seeing this on paper, it may not be the ideal scenario for each of the bats, but it does spread out playing time well. I DM'd with Kiley a bit on this and he pointed out that Gorman would receive a fifth start during the week that was missing form this chart.
In all honesty, the Cardinals could even move up Donovan into the 5 start category and take away DeJong's start. Yepez, Nootbaar, or Gorman could gain a start if Contreras gets two off days, rather than starting at DH once a week. This does not even include the potential for pitch-hit opportunities or late-game substitutions based off of matchups.
When it comes to starts for the position players each week, there are ways to keep guys in the lineup on a consistent basis. But for those of you concerned that this is not enough at-bats for their top players, I'm guessing this isn't their end goal either.
When injuries happen, this rotation will shrik even more. Say O'Neill goes down for a month, that's 5 starts a week that are now available to other guys. One injury to this group opens up playing time in a major way for the rest.
And as the season progresses, the team will be able to see which players rise to the top. If Carlson or one of the outfielders struggles, they'll be faded more in favor of the rest. If Yepez or Gorman are not hitting, their at-bats will shrink too. This construction is meant to continue this Spring Training competition into the season, and allow the best players to come out on top.
Do you think this is a fair way to balance the Cardinals playing time out to begin the season? Let us know in the comments below.