How are members of the 2023 Cardinals doing on their new teams?

Several 2023 St. Louis Cardinals members moved on to different teams for 2024. How are those players doing now?

The Cardinals made several moves at the trade line and after the season ended to improve a team with a dismal 71-91 record. John Mozeliak, president of baseball operations, promised the fans that they would bring in "pitching, pitching, pitching" to help improve their chances in 2024 and beyond.

Some fan favorites moved on from the Cardinals in the process. Those players are finding success with their new team.

Tyler O'Neill

In December, O'Neill was traded to the Boston Red Sox in exchange for Nick Robertson and Victor Santos.

The move was not surprising after O'Neill seemed to struggle to stay healthy and on the good side of manager Oli Marmol. The manager quickly threw the slugger under the bus for a perceived lack of hustle while rounding third base on a night it had been raining in St. Louis. O'Neill pulled up while rounding third base to avoid injury after struggling to stay off the injured list with various issues. O'Neill took offense to the comment as he's been known to put in lots of work to stay prepared. The player also wanted to avoid public criticism, wishing Marmol had approached him man-to-man to discuss the issue. While it was said, the two hashed things out, O'Neill and Marmol's relationship didn't appear to heal. O'Neill landed on the injured list for most of the season, making a last-month attempt to help the team.

Since joining the Red Sox, O'Neill has extended his Opening Day home run streak to five consecutive seasons. He's also performed the way fans hoped he would have for St. Louis. He's slashing .313/.459/.750 with an OPS of 1.209. He's homered seven times with 15 hits through 15 games, scoring 14 runs and 18 RBI. He's also netted one stolen base.

As a Cardinal fan, this is frustrating because it's obvious O'Neill needed to move on to have success. He was not going to put up these numbers with Marmol and the Cardinals.

After hustling out a play and concussing himself, the player has also landed himself on the injured list. O'Neill was placed on the seven-day injured list retroactive to April 16 on Thursday after a collision with Rafael Devers. He was diagnosed with a mild concussion.

Jordan Hicks

Hicks was set to be one of the most exciting relief pitchers in the Cardinals organization. But with injury and issues controlling his high-velocity pitches, it was time for the two to move on. Hicks was traded at the deadline in 2023 to the Toronto Blue Jays. He was granted free agency and signed a four-year deal worth $44 million to become a starting pitcher.

It's shocking, but of course, this is how to use the talented pitcher properly. As a starter, he will stretch out and not use as high a velocity, and he can work longer and more efficiently. If having Hicks starting was ever something desired by the front office, it must not have been taken seriously by the coaching staff as they kept putting him in situations to be a high-leverage reliever. After this became dangerous in some cases, it is shocking that there wasn't more effort to make Hicks a starter happen.

Since joining the Giants, Hicks has started four games and is 2-0 with an ERA of 1.57. In 23 innings pitched, he's given up one home run and four earned runs. He's walked six batters while striking out 18.

It's unclear if this was just a developmental issue with the Cardinals' use of Hicks, but it would have been nice to see him in a starter role considering home much another starter has been needed over the past couple of seasons.

Jack Flaherty

Hopes were high for Flaherty to become the ace of the staff. However, with several injuries, the talented young arm never found the success he had in 2019.

The organization gave Flaherty the beginning of the 2023 season to prove that he deserved an opportunity to be signed as a free agent in the offseason. The struggles mounted, and he even gave the impression that he was struggling because of the addition of catcher Willson Contreras. The youngster publicly stated he was getting a different attention to detail provided by legendary catcher Yadier Molina. While Contreras is an entirely different catcher than Molina, he puts in a lot of work with his pitching staff. Flaherty and Adam Wainwright walked back the statement within days of Flaherty saying it. The statement was made and gave Flaherty a bad look.

Flaherty was traded to the Baltimore Orioles for pitchers Drew Rom, Zack Showalter, and infielder Cesar Prieto. The Orioles ended the season with Flaherty in the bullpen. Flaherty signed a one-year deal worth $14 million with the Detroit Tigers as a free agent.

Flaherty is 0-1 in three starts with the Tigers. In 18.1 innings, he's given up ten earned runs, including three homers. While he's walked three batters, he has struck out 20 batters. He threw 14 swing-and-miss pitches in his loss to the Oakland Athletics and 16 swing-and-miss pitches against the Minnesota Twins, a no-decision.

The Cardinals made the right call to move on from Flaherty. Hopefully, he matures with his new team.

Jordan Montgomery

Montgomery fell in love with St. Louis when he was traded in 2022 from the New York Yankees for Harrison Bader. Montgomery hoped to turn a tremendous second half of the 2022 season and a full season with the Cardinals into a long-term deal with the club once he hit free agency.

Instead, Montgomery went 6-9 with the Cardinals and was traded at the deadline along with Chris Stratton to the Texas Rangers for Tekoah Roby, Thomas Saggasse, and John King. Montgomery ended up being a key piece for the Rangers in their successful bid to win a World Series Championship.

Montgomery and his agent, Scott Boras, believed he would be a hot commodity and earn a hefty contract. Montgomery was signed on March 29. He earned a one-year deal with the Arizona Diamondbacks worth $25 million and a vesting option for 2025. He's expected to debut with the D-Backs on Friday against the Giants.

Montgomery has since dropped Boras as his agent, opting to go with Joel Wolfe and Nick Chanock of Wasserman. Montgomery can use this new opportunity to improve his odds for a better contract,