3 players the Cardinals gave up on too soon
The St. Louis Cardinals gave up on these three players way too soon.
Over the years, the St. Louis Cardinals have regularly been one of the best teams at acquiring talent, whether it be through the draft, free agency, or trades. There is little doubt about that,
However, there are a handful of players that the club didn't see turning into anything special at the big league level and perhaps gave up on them a bit too soon.
There are many more possible entrants to such a list than the ones we single out. As great as the team can be at handling talent inside of the organization, even the Cardinals are not immune to misreading a player's potential and moving on before it was absolutely necessary.
Let's check out 3 players the Cardinals moved on from too soon.
Zac Gallen
Gallen, a third-round draft pick by the Cardinals in the 2016 draft, only spent a few years in the organization before he was flipped to the Miami Marlins in exchange for Marcell Ozuna. We're all intimately familiar with this deal by now, as this was also when the Cardinals lost eventual Cy Young winner Sandy Alcántara.
Gallen had posted a 2.93 ERA in 26 starts in 2017, bursting onto the scene in a big way for three different minor league affiliates. This was enough to warrant his inclusion in the Ozuna trade as the Marlins were looking for a pitcher with a high upside. Clearly, this worked out for them as they got two in one deal.
What makes his departure hard to swallow for Cardinals fans is how much success he has found at the big league level, with both the Marlins and his current club - the Arizona Diamondbacks.
Last year, Gallen was one of the National League's best starters, going 12-4 with a 2.54 ERA and 158 ERA+ in 31 starts and 184 innings. He led the league in WHIP (0.913) and hits per nine innings (5.9) and finished fifth in the Cy Young voting.
The Cardinals have assembled some solid starting rotations in the years since Gallen was gone, but I'd be lying if I said he wouldn't look great in the current starting group heading into 2023.
Patrick Wisdom
Wisdom, now a member of the division rival Chicago Cubs, was drafted in the first round of the 2012 MLB Draft by the Cardinals. Truthfully, he was nothing special for the club in the first few years of his ascent through the minor leagues.
It wasn't until 2017 when the then-25-year-old found some untapped power potential and exploded onto the scene with 31 home runs in 127 games. His strikeouts were high and he didn't hit for average very well, but he suddenly emerged as one of the top power-hitting prospects in the Cardinals' system.
He followed this up with 15 more home runs in 107 games the following season. The front office had seen enough to warrant his first promotion to the big leagues and while he hit well (139 OPS+ in 32 games), he seemed to be a boom-or-bust type of player, meaning he either hits a home run or gets out.
With the infield largely set for the Cardinals (Paul Goldschmidt at first and Matt Carpenter at third) entering 2019, Wisdom had no position for the team. He was then traded to the Texas Rangers in exchange for utilityman Drew Robinson. His Rangers career consisted of nine games and four hits with 15 strikeouts in 26 at-bats before he was cut loose.
There's no telling where exactly Wisdom would've slotted into this current Cardinals team. Over the past few years on the Cubs, he has added the corner outfield to his defensive repertoire and could potentially have a role similar to Carpenter's over the years where he bounces around from position to position and hits 25-30 home runs a year for the club.
Adolis García
García came up through the Cardinals' organization after signing as an international free agent in February of 2017. Before joining the Cards, he had already established himself as an intriguing outfield prospect in Cuba and during a brief stint in Japan.
Starting off in the organization as a 24-year-old, García did not have to wait long to make it up to Triple-A and eventually the big leagues. As a matter of fact, he was drafted in 2017 and debuted in The Show in 2018. He performed exceptionally well in the minors and showed that he at least deserved a look in the majors.
After making it into 21 games for the Cardinals, García had not shown enough to warrant another look in 2019. It's fairly easy to see why that is, as he went just two-for-17 (.118 average) with seven strikeouts and no walks. His OPS+ that year was -21.
Even if he was able to perform in the major leagues, García was blocked in 2019 by a multitude of outfield-capable players on the big league roster, including Marcell Ozuna, Harrison Bader, Dexter Fowler, José Martínez, Tommy Edman, Tyler O'Neill and Yairo Muñoz, among others.
The 2020 campaign was going to largely feature the same names in the Cardinals' outfield picture, now joined by top prospect Dylan Carlson. García had nowhere to go in the organization, despite hitting 32 home runs with 96 RBI in Triple-A the year prior.
In December 2019, the Cardinals decided to cut bait with García. He was a big-league player without a big-league roster spot. He was traded to the Texas Rangers in exchange for cash considerations and nothing more, a huge mistake by the Cards.
García went hitless in six at-bats for the Rangers in 2020, eventually being designated for assignment. He was brought back on a minor league deal entering 2021 and saw his career blossom, making the All-Star Game that year and hitting 31 home runs for Texas. He has continued to perform with his new club and is perhaps a player the Cardinals should've held onto for a bit longer.