The writing was on the wall but now it is official: The St. Louis Cardinals and Nolan Gorman will be going their separate ways. Prior to the non-tender deadline on Friday, it was reported and confirmed that the Cardinals did not tender Gorman a contract, making the lefty slugger a free agent.
At the beginning of Gorman's major league career that began as a 22-year-old, the former first-round draft pick had the potential to become a middle of the order threat for the Cardinals for years. The Cardinals forced Gorman to move to second base in an effort to get him on the fast track to the bigs after the team brought in Hall of Famer Nolan Arenado. He had extreme raw power and had 87 career minor league homers in just three seasons before being promoted during the 2022 season.
Nolan Gorman could become the Cardinals' next "what could have been" situation
Upon his promotion, Gorman held his own at the plate and played decent enough defense to become a legitimate option at second base for the future. He went into the 2023 season as the incumbent at the position while also being able to spell Arenado at the hot corner from time to time. By the end of his second season, the 23-year-old Gorman made the Cardinals look like geniuses as he popped 27 homers and drove in 76 runs in just 119 games and actually had enough success against lefty pitchers to be a true everyday option.
Unfortunately for both Gorman and the Cardinals, the 2024 season started a tailspin that Gorman was never able to fly out of. After being gifted the starting job, Gorman fumbled hard and put up a .203 average with 19 homers in 109 games while his strikeout rate exploded to an unfathomable 37.6%. His patience at the plate waned as well as his walk rate dropped below double digits for the first time, settling in at mediocre 8.5%. To make it all worse, his defense also plummeted as back issues limited his range and efficiency to create an all-around nightmare season.
The 2025 Cardinals were supposed to right the ship as an organization with Gorman hoping to become a power utility bat and DH on the strong side of a platoon. Once again, things got out of control and Gorman was sapped of power to go along with his contact issues and knocked him out of a job with the hopes time away from the game would get Gorman back on track with his swing. After the Cardinals decided that Gorman's playing time was not consistent enough to give him a proper evaluation, the Nolan Arenado deal opened up an unencumbered opportunity to get back in good graces with the organization. As we all know now, that did not work out as Gorm's 2026 season was by far the worst of his career.
Now that Gorman is on the open market, I will be interested in seeing which team decides to give the former top 100 prospect his next shot. I would not be surprised to hear of multiple teams wanting to bring him in on a minor league deal in the hopes of rediscovering the swing that made him a known power threat to the league. Whenever he signs with his next organization, Cardinals fans will surely be keeping one eye on his next move to see if he will become the next Randy Arozarena to the organization.
Depending on how many teams are interested in Gorman, there may be an organization that is willing to give him a major league contract in hopes of gaining as much value as quickly as possible in the infielder. Gorman has always been a hitter who can get extremely hot in spurts, so there may be a team that would want to take advantage of his next streak. For me, I will always be a Gorman fan who wants to see his 30+ homer potential come to fruition at the big league level, wherever it may be.
