Skip to main content

Jimmy Crooks earns trade label that's hard to refute thanks to Cardinals' catching surplus

He'll find a lot more playing time outside St. Louis.
ByBrandon Glick
St. Louis Cardinals catcher Jimmy Crooks.
St. Louis Cardinals catcher Jimmy Crooks. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

It's hardly novel to suggest that the St. Louis Cardinals should try parlaying some of their extreme catching depth into some help elsewhere on the roster via trade. Heck, I've written about the possibility numerous times, citing various reports around the trade deadline that suggested Chaim Bloom would kowtow to the economic principles of surpluses and deficits.

That has yet to happen, though don't expect the rumor mill to slow down any time soon. MLB.com's Mark Feinsand is just the latest to toss his hat in this ring, labeling Jimmy Crooks as the Redbirds' most obvious trade candidate this winter.

Jimmy Crooks is the Cardinals' most tradeable catcher this offseason

Crooks certainly didn't have a banner season in 2026, struggling badly at the MLB level again; through 195 plate appearance in the big leagues, he's now been responsible for a 51 wRC+ and -0.4 fWAR. He's not necessarily buried on the catching depth chart, but it's hard to find him a pathway toward playing time with the Cardinals barring injuries.

And, truthfully, that's the real reason Crooks is on a list like Feinsand's -- someone is going to be a victim of the numbers game. Assuming Leo Bernal is locked in as the starter with Pedro Pagés as his backup, the Cardinals already have their big-league roster set behind the plate. Considering than Iván Herrera can also catch in a pinch and will ostensibly serve as the third backstop... yeah, the picture gets bleak for Crooks quickly. And that's before even mentioning Rainiel Rodriguez, the undspited catcher of the future in St. Louis.

What will also grease the wheels of a potential Crooks trade is that he isn't without value. Sure, he hasn't yet solved major-league pitching in a small sample, but he lit up Triple-A in 2026 to the tune of a .300/.432/.574 (160 wRC+) slash line. Tack on the improved defense he showcased with the Cardinals (+4 Framing Runs) and what you have is a 25-year-old catcher with massive upside just waiting to get his opportunity.

Following Ryan Jeffers' surprising decision to accept the qualifying offer from the Twins, the free-agent market at the position is also bleak. Carson Kelly and Tyler Stephenson are the only starting-caliber catchers still available, and both are much older and will be far more expensive than a pre-arb Crooks. Other teams will be tripping over themselves to acquire him if the Cardinals make him available.

It's always possible that one of the other aforementioned catchers gets dealt instead, but if the Cardinals are only trading one player from the position this offseason, the smart money is on Crooks.

Add us as a preferred source on Google