Skip to main content

Jackson Holliday is a fun fit for Cardinals but not at Orioles current asking price

It's not fair to dismiss the fit, but the Orioles are making a potential deal hard to rationalize.
ByJosh Jacobs
Aug 26, 2026; St. Louis, Missouri, USA; Baltimore Orioles second baseman Jackson Holliday (7) looks on during the fourth inning against the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Curry-Imagn Images
Aug 26, 2026; St. Louis, Missouri, USA; Baltimore Orioles second baseman Jackson Holliday (7) looks on during the fourth inning against the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Curry-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

It's easy to see why Jackson Holliday would be a really fun fit for the St. Louis Cardinals. The son of Cardinals Hall of Famer Matt Holliday, a former number one overall pick, and a left-handed hitting infielder who could see time at third base and fit in at second or shortstop long-term as well, depending on how the Cardinals' infield shakes out.

But if the Baltimore Orioles still value him like the player we thought he was a few years ago, then a deal just isn't happening.

It's been well documented at this point that the Orioles are listening on anyone not named Pete Alonso on their Major League roster, and given the influx of young and interesting infielders they have right now, Holliday is one of the prime names who could be moved as Baltimore retools. But given his lack of Major League success to this point in his career and some very real concerns about his long-term profile, the Cardinals are not going to be giving up a loaded package to acquire his services.

Through Holliday's first 1211 plate appearances at the Major League level, he has slashed .229/.300/.354 with an 86 wRC+, far from the kind of production that the industry expected to see when he was crowned the top prospect in the sport prior to his debut. And looking beneath the hood, Holliday has struggled to consistently hit the ball hard since 2024 and has below-average bat speed, contributing to questions about how much he could really slug at the Major League level.

Still, I would not give up on him, and with Holliday being just a few weeks from turning 23 years old, I would love to see the Cardinals' hitting staff get to work with him, if the Orioles have a realistic asking price.

The Cardinals have the hitting infrastructure to unlock Jackson Holliday

If we were putting a percentage on the chance of the Cardinals making a "bigger" trade this offseason, I think it would be lower than 50%, but it's much higher than the "there's no shot" crowd would think there is. And third base is one of those spots I expect the Cardinals to continue looking at.

If the Cardinals were to bring a guy like Holliday in, it's a fun bet to make because of the combination of talent this guy has and the kind of talent the Cardinals have in their hitting group right now that could help unlock him.

Dalton Hurd and Brock Hammitt get a ton of praise beyond the scenes, both locally and around baseball, for their work with young hitters. Casey Chenoweth is a highly respected voice on the Cardinals' Major League roster, credited with helping Jordan Walker revive his career. And new coach Joel McKeithan has been helping young hitters succeed in the Majors and has specifically seen power gains from clubs he coaches.

Walker, Joshua Baez, Jesus Baez, and Tai Peete are among some of the young bats in the Cardinals system who have seen tremendous gains in their production since this new hitting group came along (Walker and Joshua Baez) or since being acquired by St. Louis with that group in place (Jesus Baez and Peete). Could Holliday be the next in that line?

Right now, you're probably talking about one of the Cardinals' very best prospects, plus more, to get Holliday in the door. But if Baltimore were willing to take a strong package that did not center on the Cardinals' top five prospects and/or were willing to swap some Major League talent, I could really see it being worth the gamble.

If I were St. Louis, I would look at taking the cost control of Michael McGreevy, Jimmy Crooks, and maybe another smaller prospect to see what that could do. The Orioles are seeking cost-controlled pitching for their rotation, outfield help, and potentially a catcher, so the Cardinals make a lot of sense here.

The Orioles have to be honest with themselves - unless they are adding pieces to the deal to go along with Holliday, they aren't acquiring a pitcher with cost control who also has high upside. But they could get a dependable starter like McGreevy on the cheap, plus other pieces, to help fill out their roster.

For the Cardinals, if the price did come down, it's an interesting bet to make if they do see a path toward helping Holliday reach his upside. There are people within the Cardinals organization who would love to acquire Holliday, so it will be interesting to see if a deal could come to fruition.

Add us as a preferred source on Google