Skip to main content

Former Cardinals ace Dustin May just set the starting pitcher market with a hefty contract

Mayday, mayday. Holy payday.
ByAJ Stone
World Series: Tampa Bay Rays v Milwaukee Brewers - Game Two
World Series: Tampa Bay Rays v Milwaukee Brewers - Game Two | Michael Reaves/GettyImages

Former half-season Cardinals’ ace Dustin May has reportedly signed a three-year deal worth just above $50 million with the Chicago White Sox, per FanSided’s Robert Murray. 

Dustin May agrees to three-year contract with White Sox

May, 29, joined the Cardinals after a tumultuous start to his MLB career. Injuries limited his ability to impact his team, and his aura as a former top Dodgers prospect was fading. 

That’s why May came to The Lou. It was a do-over. A fresh start. And “Big Red,” as he became known, took advantage of said freshness. 

May tossed 109 innings for the Cardinals to a 4.28 ERA. That included a complete-game, one-hit shutout against a star-studded Padres lineup. 

His 109 innings were the most he’d thrown for one team in a season throughout his career. Furthermore, his underlying marks of a 3.15 FIP, with great extension and velocity, left potential trade suitors enamored. 

The Milwaukee Brewers salivated the most, as they forked over Alexander Frias and Josiah Ragsdale for May and reliever JoJo Romero at the deadline. According to MLB Pipeline, Frias is the Cardinals' fifth-best prospect, and Ragsdale is 11th.  

May wasn’t as good in Milwaukee–until the playoffs. 

In 36.2 regular-season innings, the big-righty showed glimpses of old problems. His ERA crept up to 5.65 with The Crew, and his walks and home runs per nine both declined. 

May didn’t let those late-season woes affect his shot at a ring. Across three different series, he tossed 11 innings for the Brewers and surrendered seven runs. Was it pretty? Not whatsoever. But it got the job done. 

Milwaukee won its first World Series in 2026, and May contributed. He rebuilt himself in the NL Central, first by Bird, then by Beer. 

Now, the White Sox are taking a major gamble. 

Chicago finished last season as a playoff team, which was more surprising than almost any other MLB storyline. 

In the playoffs, the Sox displayed a rowdy, careless energy. Like they were excited to be there, but didn’t feel the October heat. It was a refreshing brand of baseball, and from a temperament standpoint, May will fit in just fine. 

From a baseball angle, the Sox starting rotation was projected to be: Sean Burke, Davis Martin, Anthony Kay, Luis Castillo, and newly announced closer-turned-starter, Grant Taylor. 

That’s a whoooooole lot of volatility addressed by bringing in one of the market's most volatile arms. 

The most likely swap is with the veteran, Castillo. He looked like a shell of himself all of last season, and with this addition, the White Sox seem to be scaling competitiveness rather than reveling in it. 

May is talented. The Sox are talented, but can they get in sync? Can he stay on the field and perform? Can a young, dumb White Sox roster make the playoffs again? 

Those questions, and many more, surround what’s sure to be a landmark signing this offseason. Dustin May just earned over $50 million after boasting a 4.88 ERA last season. Metrics are phenomenal, but they aren’t the whole truth. 

The Cardinals escaped that deal. In exchange, they landed two elite prospects from the Brewers system and can pivot to a more affordable free agent option. 

All the best to May in the Windy City. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google