Skip to main content

Cardinals fans may be apprehensive after freefalls from highly touted Chaim Bloom prospects

Are some potential draft busts on the horizon?
ByJ.T. Buchheit
Tampa Bay Rays v St. Louis Cardinals
Tampa Bay Rays v St. Louis Cardinals | Dilip Vishwanat/GettyImages

Chaim Bloom is giving St. Louis Cardinals fans a reason for optimism regarding the direction of the franchise, as the farm system is brimming with high-upside talent that looks primed to contribute to the next competitive Cardinals squad. But while St. Louis fans are going gaga over Bloom and the players he's acquired, fans of the Boston Red Sox, the organization whose roster Bloom was in charge of from 2020 through 2023, may be offering a word of caution toward Cardinals supporters regarding the future of their stud prospects.

Kristian Campbell was considered a can't-miss prospect as recently as 2025. Campbell, a second baseman and outfielder whom Boston drafted 132nd overall under the Bloom regime in 2023, tore through three minor league levels in 2024, hitting .330 with a .997 OPS in 517 plate appearances. His performance led MLB Pipeline to name him as the No. 7 overall prospect in baseball in 2025, but he faceplanted in his major league opportunity, hitting .223 with a .664 OPS and playing poor to mediocre defense, and the Red Sox are now reportedly mulling over the idea of designating Campbell for assignment.

Given the mammoth contract that Campbell just signed, it's highly unlikely that any team would be willing to take the plunge and eat all of that money; rather, this is Boston's way to clear a spot on their 40-man roster to protect someone from the Rule 5 draft, which Campbell would not be eligible for after his eight-year contract extension.

Still, the speculation that Boston would pull off such a move put Campbell's struggles into perspective and led to discussion about other one-time top prospects from the Bloom era who have faltered over their careers, such as Marcelo Mayer, MLB Pipeline's 12th-ranked prospect in 2025, who hit just .223 with a .625 OPS in 364 Boston plate appearances before being shipped to the San Francisco Giants at the 2026 trade deadline.

Kristian Campbell's and Marcelo Mayer's failures can't keep Cardinals fans up at night

Campbell and Meyer have received plenty of criticism from fans after floundering at the highest level, and it's easy to see how the lack of performance from two high-level Bloom prospects could have Cardinals fans gnawing on their fingernails. Those who look at the other first-round picks with Boston under Bloom may not initially see much to assuage those concerns, either.

The Red Sox' first picks from 2020 to 2023 consisted of Nick Yorke, Marcelo Mayer, Mikey Romero and Kyle Teel. Yorke has a career OPS+ of 62 (with 100 being average), Mayer's is 71, and Romero has yet to debut in the major leagues but hit just .239 with a .680 OPS in Triple-A in 2026. Teel was a bright spot in 2025, albeit with the Chicago White Sox, holding a 121 OPS+ before missing much of 2026 with injuries.

The numbers of the first three players appear grim, but Boston may have never had outsized expectations for some of their first-round picks. Of the four aforementioned players, only Mayer was signed at slot value; the others were signed below slot value. In other words, outside of Mayer, the Red Sox signed chose first-rounders who they knew were lesser talents than many others in their draft range in order to spend more money on later picks, such as Roman Anthony, whom Boston drafted 79th in 2022 and signed well above slot value to persuade him to sign with the Red Sox and forgo college.

Additionally, while Mayer has not yet proven that he was worth the fourth overall pick in 2021, Campbell's situation is quite different. Boston drafted Campbell with the 132nd overall pick in 2023 and signed him exactly at slot value: $492,700. Given his lower draft position than most big-time prospects, few would have batted an eyelash had he faltered in the minor leagues and never made a peep.

It was only through Campbell's massive success at the lower levels that he found his way to the major leagues and into widespread consciousness among baseball fans. Campbell wouldn't have been scrutinized so much had he never begun to materialize in the first place.

The Cardinals can empathize with the Red Sox' plight regarding Campbell, as Jordan Walker faced a similar situation. The 2020 first-round pick razed the minor leagues, and after some initial major league success, he failed to adapt to how he was being pitched to and was among the worst hitters in the majors in 2024 and 2025 before breaking out in 2026 under the tutelage of assistant hitting coach Casey Chenoweth.

Chenoweth's presence made all the difference for Walker, and it's possible that Campbell and Mayer could develop further if another coach can unlock their potential. This is where MLB The Show fails to reflect real life: In the video games, a player has a set "potential" attribute, and there's little that the person playing the game can do to affect it. But real development is far less linear and generally depends on a myriad of factors, including coaching and a player's willingness and ability to absorb instruction.

The overhauled staff at the lower levels for the Cardinals under Bloom has already made massive strides with many young players, and there's no reason to believe that the team will fall back into its old, outdated habits when it comes to prospect development. It's true that two high-profile prospects from Bloom's Boston days haven't panned out yet, but Cardinals fans can't let their confidence in their new leader waver when there are so many variants at play.

Add us as a preferred source on Google