
Conclusion
Whether it’s East Coast/Yankees media bias, a couple of awe-inspiring plays that will be featured in MLB highlight reels until the end of time, World Series titles, or some combination of all these factors and more, ESPN’s writers determined Derek Jeter is a better player than Albert Pujols.
That’s their prerogative, of course. Inevitably, voting for something like this has a personal slant to it, much more so than Hall of Fame voting, and we all know how contentious that can be. But when the intangible, inexplicable factors are taken out of the equation and the numbers and facts are examined, the answer is clear: Pujols has been a better major-league baseball player than Derek Jeter. To try to argue differently is to ignore reality.