St. Louis Cardinals: Revisiting the two critical trades from 2011

John Mozeliak made two critical trades in July of 2011 which helped propel the struggling St. Louis Cardinals to their 11th World Championship. The trades didn’t make an immediate impact, but they paid off during the September chase for the postseason.

Coming out of the All-Star Break on July 15, 2011, the St. Louis Cardinals found themselves tied with the Milwaukee Brewers for first place in the NL Central. Nevertheless, with only a 49-43 record, the Cardinals weren’t exactly cooking and were facing several issues with their roster.

The Cardinals co-ace, Adam Wainwright, had Tommy John surgery during the off-season and would miss the entire 2011 season. Ryan Franklin had struggled in the closer’s role and would be released in June. In fact, the whole bullpen would be reworked before the end of the season, with only Mitchell Boggs and Jason Motte surviving to the end of the season.

Additionally, Ryan Theriot, who had been traded to the Cardinals to be the primary shortstop in the off-season, was struggling at the position and would commit 17 errors in 2011. Colby Rasmus, considered to be a five-tool prospect and was expected to be the next great Cardinal center fielder, was struggling at the plate, hitting .194 since May. By July, Rasmus, who had been feuding with Manager Tony LaRussa, was on his way out.

Enter General Manager John Mozeliak, who would engineer the two trades which would resolve these issues and eventually propel the Cardinals to the World Series.

The First Trade

On July 27, Mozeliak executed a four-for-four trade which involved the unhappy and struggling Rasmus, left-handed relievers Trever Miller and Brian Tallet, and starter P.J. Walters to the Toronto Blue Jays. In return, the Cardinals received, right-handed starter Edwin Jackson, left-handed specialist, Marc Rzepczynski, right-handed reliever Octavio Dotel, and outfielder Corey Patterson.

The trade moved Jackson into the starter’s role and allowed the Cardinals to move the reliable and versatile Kyle McClellan, who had taken Wainwright’s spot in the rotation, back into the bullpen. Jackson would be a steady rotation piece for the rest of 2011, throwing for 78 innings with a 5-2 record and a 3.58 ERA.

Rzepczynski and Dotel both helped solidify the bullpen. The 26-year old Rzepczynski had a 3.97 ERA after arriving with the Cardinals but was dominant in October. He allowed only one earned run in nine appearances during the NLCS and WS. Dotel, meanwhile, had a 3.28 ERA in 29 games after arriving from Toronto and allowed only three earned runs in 12 appearances during the postseason.

Jon Jay replaced Rasmus in center field and provided a steady defensive glove. Jay also had a slash line of .297/.344/.424, 10 home runs, and an OPS+ of 112 in 159 games during 2011.

The Second Trade

Just before the non-waiver trade deadline on July 31, Mozeliak sent AA outfielder Alex Castellanos to the Los Angeles Dodgers for shortstop Rafael Furcal. The acquisition of Furcal allowed the Cardinals to tighten up their defense going into the stretch run of 2011, and move Theriot to a bench/pinch-hitting role.

The switch-hitting Furcal hit a slash line of .255/.316/.418 with seven home runs and 16 RBI in only 50 games. However, it was during the stretch run in September that Furcal was at his best. In 23 games, he had .275 BA, hit four homers, six doubles, and eight RBI with an OPS of .819. Additionally, he became a reliable leadoff hitter for the Cardinals, drawing 17 walks after he arrived.

But it was mainly the 33-year old’s range at shortstop which help the Cardinals during the stretch run of August and September. After he arrived in St. Louis, his Rtot/yr was 2, compared to Theriot’s -16.

After the Trades

The effects of the two trades weren’t felt immediately. The Cardinals had gone 13-13 in July and in August, they went 15-13, falling behind the NL Central leaders, Milwaukee Brewers by 8.5 games. Worse, the Cardinals seemed to have fallen out of the Wild Card race also, trailing the Atlanta Braves by 10.5 games as late as August 24.