All across Major League Baseball today, teams are forced to make a decision on whether or not to tender their arbitration- and pre-arbitration-eligible players a contract or allow them to hit free agency. For the St. Louis Cardinals, they have to come face to face with the fates of players who were long considered part of their future core.
Tendering a contract to a player this offseason puts the Cardinals on the hook for paying that player and/or going to arbitration to find out what that salary will end up being, barring a trade at a later date.
Nolan Gorman is the Cardinals clear non-tender candidate
Doesn't it feel like the end of the line for Nolan Gorman? There's plenty of talent in the bat of this 26-year-old, but it appears that both sides could use a change of scenery.
Drafted in the first round of the 2018 MLB Draft, Gorman became a top prospect in the sport prior to his debut in 2022, and during his first full big-league season in 2023, he mashed 27 home runs in just 119 games while posting an eye-popping 118 wRC+ and a .478 slugging percentage, which are awesome numbers for a rookie with some real swing-and-miss issues.
Unfortunately, those swing-and-miss concerns just grew louder and louder for Gorman, as each year since his great rookie campaign, Gorman has been well below average as a hitter and has tumbled out of his status as a promising young bat and into a clear non-tender candidate.
Perhaps Gorman can find a way to consistently make contact with a new organization and unlock his power once again, but the way that the Cardinals talk about Gorman compared to other players on their roster, it doesn't sound like St. Louis believes it will happen here.
Gorman is projected to make $3.4 million in arbitration in 2027, making the decision even easier to move on from the struggling third baseman.
Victor Scott II and Cesar Prieto would make senes for the Cardinals to move on from
Neither player is arbitration-eligible this year, but both Victor Scott II and Cesar Prieto have struggled mightily during their time in the big leagues, and there are a lot of reasons to move on prior to today's deadline.
For Prieto, it's clear that he has no path toward a starting role with the Cardinals in the future, and it's even difficult to see how he'll be a consistent reserve player, either. And with more infield talent pressing up through the upper levels of the minor leagues, it makes sense to create room for those players to play as often as possible.
For Scott, he was almost 50% below average at the plate in 2026, one of the worst hitters in Major League Baseball, and also struggled to find his footing at Triple-A as well. Scott tried to get some work in this offseason at the Dominican Winter League, but he also could not hit there, and his time with that club ended prematurely.
The Cardinals are set to have Tai Peete, Josiah Ragsdale, Colton Ledbetter, Chase Davis, and more looking for plate appearances in Memphis next year, and all of those names are also left-handed bats who want to show they can play center field.
If I had to guess, Scott does not return to the Cardinals next year with all of the outfield talent they want to see develop. They've committed to Nathan Church as their center fielder and have Everson Pereira as a right-handed platoon option, and names like Bryan Torres, Jose Fermin, and even Thomas Saggese can play out there as needed.
While it's not as clear as Gorman seems to be, I feel pretty confident that both Prieto and Scott will no longer be Cardinals after the deadline passes.
