June 28, 2012; San Francisco, CA, USA; Cincinnati Reds starting pitcher Johnny Cueto (47) picks off San Francisco Giants catcher Buster Posey (not pictured) at first base during the fourth inning at AT

A message to Johnny Cueto: Shut up!


With the All Star rosters being announced yesterday, it was expected that there would be talk of snubs and miscues. It was easy to see mistakes, chiefly Pablo Sandoval being voted in as a starter. There were also many worthy players left off the roster thanks to the fan voting procedure and the rule that every team must be represented. There was one team however that had problems with the selection process: the Cincinnati Reds. Namely Johnny Cueto and Brandon Phillips.

Yahoo originally reported on this and I personally find it to be hilarious. Of the two players, Cueto was more upset about things than Phillips.

 “I see that I have great numbers,” Cueto said. “I thought the way I pitched this year, I’d have a chance to go to the All-Star Game. I don’t know what happened. I don’t if know the manager of All-Star Game is pissed at me because I went out with one of his girlfriends.”

All this quote shows is exactly why Cueto wasn’t chosen. Among pitchers, LaRussa’s picks were Cole Hamels, Jonathan Papelbon, Clayton Kershaw, Wade Miley, and Huston Street. Of those five pitchers, the only questionable choice was Huston Street. His selection, however, was caused by the fan vote of Pablo Sandoval. Since Sandoval got the start, David Wright had to be the backup. This all pushed Chase Headley out, meaning Street had to be the Padres representative. The battle really comes down to the starting pitchers. The following chart shows that the only stat Cueto leads the way is his ERA.

Name Team W L SV G GS IP K/9 BB/9 HR/9 BABIP HR/FB ERA FIP xFIP WAR
Johnny Cueto Reds 9 4 0 16 16 107.2 6.60 2.09 0.42 0.292 0.054 2.26 3.11 3.76 2.6
Clayton Kershaw Dodgers 6 4 0 17 17 115.1 8.74 2.34 0.86 0.262 0.104 2.65 3.18 3.28 2.4
Cole Hamels Phillies 10 4 0 16 16 111 9.00 2.27 0.97 0.282 0.115 3.08 3.27 3.23 2.4
Wade Miley Diamondbacks 8 4 0 13 13 85.1 6.75 1.58 0.63 0.267 0.069 2.85 3.07 3.63 2.2

Miley is really the only pitcher that it can be argued that Cueto has an advantage statistically over, and he made the team because the Diamondbacks needed a representative. The only other option would have been Aaron Hill, which would have still kept Brandon Phillips out of the game. Not to mention, even disregarding the fact that Tony didn’t choose Cueto, Cueto’s own peers opted not to vote him in. Maybe Cueto is right and this is all because a grudge is being held, but he need only blame himself if his fellow players don’t want to support someone who kicked wildly at other players with metal spikes on. Regardless of which group decided not to vote Cueto in, there is another problem that arises.

Name W L SV G GS IP K/9 BB/9 HR/9 BABIP HR/FB ERA FIP xFIP WAR
Player A 9 4 0 16 16 107.2 6.60 2.09 0.42 0.292 5.40% 2.26 3.11 3.76 2.6
Player B 9 2 0 16 16 102 9.00 1.94 0.35 0.329 5.60% 2.82 2.21 2.71 3.6

Now obviously since the stats are the same as the table above, it is obvious to see that Player A is Johnny Cueto. Player B, however, has vastly superior stats and was also left off the roster. He also plays for an NL Central team and one that the Cardinals had a couple of dust-ups with last year at that. Player B is Zack Greinke. If Greinke hasn’t complained about not making it, then Cueto should keep his mouth shut.

Tags: All-Star Game Featured Popular

  • Pingback: A message to Johnny Cueto: Shut up! • St.-Louis-Cardinals.fans-talk.com

  • DolphRudager

    The obvious solution is take away the 1-per-team representative rule & fan voting.  Go to an automatic point system so the most deserving get in & none of this “popular players getting in with average stats” b.s. & make the roster a hard 25 per team. The ASG is such a stupid farce of a joke I don’t even care or vote for it anymore.  Who wants to see a bunch of Red Sox & Yankees starters, or 2nd, 3rd, 4th & 5th stringers playing most of the game?

  • http://yardsellr.com/yardsale/John-Weitzman-124454 johnwvideo

    You know what ?? WHO cares about Cueto !!   He is a 2 bit punk with a big mouth that someone should kick it right threw to his A…   He and Baker, I wish that idiot would retire..
    Phillips on the other hand is a pro. I dont expect him to be in anger and a baby about it..
     
    Personnel  I would LOVE to beat the S….. Out of Cueto just for his kicking Jason in the head for a career ending  concussion , he is a NON professional  and thee REDS can keep him and the rest of the baby Cardinals that are on that team.. including Walt..
     
    I dont like the fan vote, there should be a 25 vote max “like they say”  but it does not work, if you wait 24 hours you can do it all over again or switch emails back and forth all day. So one fan can actually do 1000 votes and there are idiots out there that do it..  Heck I did over 100 for Yadie..
     
    It never ends with this idiot, I CANT WAIT for the 3 game series in Cincy, I hope someone nails that sh….birds him right in the head.