Analysis: Did the St. Louis Cardinals Spend Too Much on Carlos Beltran?

Carlos Beltran is the newest member of the St. Louis Cardinals, signing a very generous two-year/$26 million deal with a full no-trade clause. There was plenty of speculation in recent days that the Cardinals were interested in Beltran, Coco Crisp and Cody Ross to add depth to the outfield. With the departure of Albert Pujols, general manager John Mozeliak and the Cardinals were looking to get a bat for the middle of the lineup, preferably a righty. Beltran is a switch-hitter with good splits from each side. In Beltran they get a polished veteran who can hit anywhere from 3rd to 5th in the lineup. His injury history is well documented and does make this a risky signing. Did the Cardinals overstep here? A full analysis of the signing follows.

Beltran had a rejuvenation of sorts in 2011. After a poor and injury riddled 2010, he was able to put together a fine season beginning with the New York Mets, and then with the San Francisco Giants after a trade deadline deal. He ended 2011 with 22 home runs, 84 RBI and 78 R in 142 games and a 4.7 WAR. Beltran’s stat line for the last six seasons is below.


2006 29 NYM 140 617 127 38 41 116 18 .275 .388 .594 .982
2007 30 NYM 144 636 93 33 33 112 23 .276 .353 .525 .878
2008 31 NYM 161 706 116 40 27 112 25 .284 .376 .500 .876
2009 32 NYM 81 357 50 22 10 48 11 .325 .415 .500 .915
2010 33 NYM 64 255 21 11 7 27 3 .255 .341 .427 .768
2011 34 NYM 98 419 61 30 15 66 3 .289 .391 .513 .904
2011 34 SFG 44 179 17 9 7 18 1 .323 .369 .551 .920
14 Seasons 1768 7730 1184 390 302 1146 293 .283 .361 .496 .857
Provided by View Original Table
Generated 12/22/2011.


I chose to go back six years so you could see how impressive Beltran was once upon a time. He has been able to ride those numbers much longer than one would expect especially with the injury issues that have plagued him over the last few seasons. Something that made him so great, his speed is non-existent now. Give Beltran (and his agent Dan Lozano) credit for finding a team to give him two years at $26 million with a full no trade clause. I don’t want to say the Cardinals were desperate, but they may have overreached here.

That said, since they are not paying Pujols, maybe they feel they have the ability to take a risk like Beltran on and at a premium. I’m not going to suggest that the Cardinals should have gone in another direction either. They felt they needed a little pop in the middle of the lineup and some depth in the outfield. Beltran, when healthy, will provide that. The but the “healthy” part is the issue. Even last year when he had a very good season, he missed 20 games. In 2010, he missed 98 games. In 2009 he missed 81 games. The Cardinals can ill afford to have Beltran playing in that few games in either 2012 or 2013.

Using the simple WAR calculator created by Lewie Pollis at Yahoo’s On First,  I ran some simulations for Beltran below.

Before we can review the chart, I’ll remind you that Beltran’s 2011 WAR of 4.7 is an important factor. It was a very good season no doubt. But, are we (and are the Cardinals) making more of it because he’s been hurt so often over the last couple seasons? Bill James seems to think so, just based on his games played projections for Beltran. I entered James’ projections for Beltran in 2012 and an estimation for 2013 with a proportional drop of ten games. The next is a proportional increase to 140 games giving Beltran the benefit of the doubt. The last is with a detrimental season in the mix of 81 games. It shows exactly the monetary damage the signing can do if Beltran does not reach 140 games each season.

By conducting a break even analysis (above) where 1 WAR equals $5 million in the first season and the following season has a 5% inflation increase in value, we can determine the production Beltran would have to generate in order to make due on the contract terms. We take the $26 million he will earn and divide that by the total of $10.25 million. The result is multiplied by the two seasons and we get a combined WAR of 5.1. Beltran would have to have seasons which resemble the 140 game type above, twice, for the Cardinals to come out ahead. Two seasons exactly as James projects comes up just short. Any of the other scenarios combined with the 81 game season would be a significant loss for their investment. A season where Beltran plays in only 81 games is not out of the question and could be said to be likely. This isn’t a 27 year-old coming off injury. He’ll be 35 in April. I just don’t see a replication of 2011.

Obviously the Cardinals felt that they needed to take on this risk in order to make their lineup more productive. Of the options available to them, Beltran is admittedly the better of the bunch. However, they reached on the contract amount and went above and beyond reason with a full no-trade clause. I wish him the best and for the Cardinals’ sake, hope that I’m proved wrong. Mind you, I am not questioning his ability to produce, I am questioning his ability to stay on the field in order to produce. The Cardinals took a risk, one in which they can look very smart or incredibly bad. Beltran gets $26 million either way.

You can ‘Like’ Redbird Rants on Facebook here. You can follow Redbird Rants on Twitter at @FSRedbirdRants and Christopher Carelli on Twitter at @BaseballStance.

Next Cardinals Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:15Pittsburgh PiratesBuy Tickets

Tags: Albert Pujols Cardinals Carlos Beltran Coco Crisp Cody Ross John Mozeliak St Louis Cardinals WAR

  • antoinettedyer

    @ShowCars1 whats up hunny we should talk. message me at yahoo at outrageousat or aim at demetrastar

  • janinelittle1

    @jas9889 was up baby we should talk. message me on yahoo at naughtypeaceful or aim at demetrastar

  • AazobaYuzuki

    Beltran is useless! lol good luck

  • Chris_Carelli


    Not sure I would go that far

  • Marilyncolor


  • johnwvideo

    @AazobaYuzuki I would not go that far at all, unless your a disappointed Mets fan ! There is no reason to even think Beltran wont produce at least a 4WAR and Chris, I would think 25 to 30 HR are more in line with 80 to 90 RBI depending on where he bats. I watched him last season, he looked like his old self except he has lost hos speed..I think you are under on your estimates for 2012 ,He will definitely help this line up. NO ONE will replace Albert, but this will help and with Waino back there combined WAR should replace what they lost in Albert,.

  • Chris_Carelli

    @johnwvideo If you click on the link for Bill James’ projections you’ll see he’s got Beltran for 20 HR and 79 RBI in 128 games. This is definitely good production, but the RBI are not a factor in determining WAR for the method I used. You can actually go the calculator too and play around with it. Anyway, I don’t doubt he can be productive, I just don’t know if he can play two seasons and play 280 games total. If he does good for the Cardinals. The basis for the post was about costs/risks. There was not a better option, I just think they went above his value considering the obvious health factors.

  • johnwvideo

    @BaseballStance I am old fashioned, I cant stand the symmetrics or what ever they call it :) I understand your cost risk, And I do agree they paid to much, But its only 2 years.. When Craig is back, and really thats an unknown at this time though they would like to believe May, If he stays healthy as well Furcal, it will definitely help ease the loss of Albert. I should include Berkman in that as well. Good read though !

  • Chris_Carelli

    @johnwvideo Thanks, and in the end I agree he will most likely help the team, at least in one of the seasons if not both. I think the Cards felt they could absorb some extra risk and cost due to the Pujols savings thus the deal.

  • thebaseballfish


    Health is a big question here, but Beltran is still a heck of a player. I think two things need to be factored in when projecting his impact: park effect and lineup strength.

    While Citi Field, AT&T Park and the new Busch are all pitchers parks, Citi strikes me as more of a HR suppressing environment (I’m sure someone can reference the data to back up or refute that statement). I wouldn’t be surprised to see Beltran surpass 30 HR in 2012.

    The Cardinals lineup will be without Albert, but top-to-bottom, it will still be better than anything he was a part of in NY or SF.

    Beltran has also been a better player when he has something to play for so that should help augment his numbers in StL. It’s a baseball town with a strong franchise and what I perceive to be strong leadership in the clubhouse. They also have a good shot to win or be in the running for the NL central crown both seasons. These things will all help keep him “engaged.”

    My assessment comes as a Royals fan so take it for what it is worth, but I think it was an excellent move by the Cardinals and a very fair deal for both sides.

  • johnwvideo

    @thebaseballfish@BaseballStance You said that really well, Citified is more of a pitcher park then Busch.

    I hate the Mets but always have loved Beltran so I would watch him up here when and while he was healthy, and of course at every Cards series in NY, Actually MLB Hot stove went over your exact stance on each park. I agree with you on what I call the “Albert effect ” The line up with out Albert, from top to bottom. NOW This is just s dream but could you imagine that lineup with Alebrt. Its still a great line up for Beltran to be in like you said, much better then the Mets or Giants.

    A KC Fan, thats great, there was a time way long ago I went to school in KC and lived in the Blue Ridge Apts, next to Kauffman park or stadium. We would walk over to the park in the 9th and get paid to clean up the seats. For me it was fun and a job while in school..

    I have to say , this is why I like reading the Rants, Rob Rains, and NOT the PD. Here and on Robs site the postings are NOT filled with trolls looking for trouble, just good baseball fans communicating,.

    Your comment was made as a Royals fan and I agree with what you said,. By the way there is also an I 70 column that runs with all of MO sports.. Not sure if you knew that.

    As well Rob Rains dot com and always we have the Rants.

  • thebaseballfish

    @johnwvideo Yup I know about I70 – I have a solid relationship with Bill Ivie and he links up a lot of the Royals and Cardinals stuff we publish over on Seedlings to Stars.

    Thanks for the comments and thanks for sharing the story of your experiences in KC – that’s pretty cool.